The Case for a New SFA.

Avatar By

Homunculus My comment to John was genuine rather than sarcastic as …

Comment on The Case for a New SFA. by Bryce Curdy.

My comment to John was genuine rather than sarcastic as I’ve no doubt he realised.  He is a class act, although I thought he was unfair yesterday as he has acknowledged to a degree.   If you care to read back my original post i think you’ll realise your error.  And I’m not having a go at you.  I enjoy your contributions to the blog as much as I enjoy JC’s, honestly.  
But to you and jean7brodie, I respectfully disagree.  BlueGrass is getting TDd solely because he’s a Sevco fan, and that’s as childish as it is pathetic, and I think this blog should be better than that.  He is simply not being treated with the same respect as fans of other clubs and anyone denying this needs a serious dose of reality.

Bryce Curdy Also Commented

The Case for a New SFA.
Big Pink
Despite earlier comments, and despite their limitations I’m not sure I agree about the thumbs.  So long as posters use them in a fair and reasonable manner they definitely have a role.  Many of us work full time and struggle to read every single post on the blog.  Some of the lengthier ones are sometimes the best but not always.
And if you actually think that you should just bin them and then you wouldn’t have to put up with posts like mine tonight!

The Case for a New SFA.
Did you delete your comment or was it the mods?  Either way I didn’t call you anything.  How could I possibly know how you had thumbsed somebody else’s posts?  In any case, despite tonight’s spat I genuinely enjoy what you bring to the blog.  I think you’re quite recent and I’m a bit sporadic and haven’t posted much lately hence we’re unfamiliar with each other.
i think I was very vaguely aware there was some history but can’t recall anything first hand.  So that makes a bit more sense.  But if the mods have allowed him back then that’s good enough for me.  I don’t think fans of the Ibrox club should have higher pass marks than fans of other clubs.  And I managed to get myself banned once from the blog and you can see how reasonable I am 12.  It was actually a huge misunderstanding to be fair.

The Case for a New SFA.
JC 5:26 pm
Your’re a classy act as usual. I see I’ve got 44 TDs, only a few less than the TUs, but not a single comment as to why, just like BlueGrass.

Recent Comments by Bryce Curdy

Time for Scots Government to Take Bull by the Horns
I’ve not posted on the site for many months having contributed regularly previously. I have thought carefully about the repercussions of next Wednesday’s announcement and suspect many will disagree with what I’m about to state, but here goes:
i would rather see the Supreme Court reverse the CoS decision than for them to uphold it but there to be no consequences, which is what I fear will happen. If the Supreme Court find against HMRC then I will reluctantly accept that Rangers’ use of EBTs was within the letter of the law by the proverbial bawhair. It will of course leave the wee tax case and the five EBT recipients referred to above by Highlander unresolved. For the CoS decision to be upheld but ignored will forever leave a foul taste in my mouth.

THAT Debate, and the Beauty of Hindsight
‘Honest mistakes’ do happen. The problems start when there is a statistically unlikely excess of them either to the benefit or detriment of any particular club. To the best of my knowledge neither Real Madrid nor Bayern Munich have been favourably or harshly treated in recent seasons so I am willing to accept RM got lucky last night. But if the same sort of thing happens in the SF I will be much more sceptical, and if it happens again in the final I will change my opinion. And a single random decision going against them next season will not significantly change that position.

i don’t believe there is a conspiracy in Scottish football, but I do think there is institutionalised bias.  There is also considerable rank incompetence which helps dilute the bias signal.

The Day I was on the Scotland U-23 Bench
The two posts by Smugas and Big Pink immediately preceding this post are likely to form the basis of an end-of-season huge elephant in the room.  Celtic will win the league, Aberdeen and Sevco will likely finish second and third, or third and second respectively, with Hearts probably coming in fourth.  If UEFA’s regulations are applied correctly then I believe BP is correct; the default position would be that Celtic, Aberdeen and Hearts would qualify for Europe and the SFA would have to justify special dispensation re FFP for Sevco to receive a place at the expense of Hearts.  But you can bet your mortgage the MSM will have the default position as Rangers (sic) qualifying by default and active manipulation from the authorities being required for Hearts to be awarded qualification in their place.  The sleekit MSM realise how important it is to define and manage expectations making it so much easier for the utterly corrupt SFA to cheat yet again.  I sincerely hope Mrs Budge realises this already.

Edit – Homunculus posted while I was typing. Alludes to very similar.

History, Neighbours and Made Up News
Tayred, Highlander
Any Celtic fan I have ever spoken to about the matter would bite your hand off for Scotland to use foreign referees.  There is a dedicated thread on the Kerrydalestreet forum called Ref Watch I think.  Nearly everyone acknowledges that we have benefitted from two decisions not just in our favour but in a row!  The in a row bit honestly feels unheralded.  In my lifetime I am utterly convinced that up until liquidation Rangers benefitted from an X point handicap compared to Celtic and the other clubs every season of my life.  The quantity of X is up for debate and varied from season to season.

History, Neighbours and Made Up News
Highlander 08:07
I accept that Celtic have benefitted from a couple of dubious refereeing decisions at the start of this season, but disagree entirely that this is the norm and part of a bigger picture where Celtic as a ‘supposed giant’ benefit consistently rather than randomly at the expense of ‘the diddy teams’.  I will not pass comment on any other ‘supposed Giants’.  My memory is perhaps a little selective but I honestly believe that overall we have suffered more than we have gained over my lifetime (49th birthday next month) as a Celtic supporter.  And before you or anybody challenges me on this reflect that cited proof that ‘these things even themselves out’ includes a thrown in on the half way line in the 1989 Cup Final and an incorrectly awarded corner against Motherwell in 2008.

About the author